Quality Becoming a Factor in Google Reviews

Google Local Algorithm Valuing Quantity and Quality

It is universally understood that Google Places uses a different algorithm in determining relevancy of local listings. Unlike organic search, which relies on such elements as keywords and site structure, local search draws primarily on physical location and local relevancy.

While much less is known about Google’s local algorithm, it is very clear that in the past reviews and testimonials left by customers were an important factor in Google’s determination of offline business traffic and subsequent online relevancy and ranking. In short, the more online reviews a business had the better.

However, Google recently published a YouTube video which highlighted the top three factors that influence local search:

  • Relevance: only showing businesses that match the search query;
  • Prominence: a measure of how “well-known” a business is (i.e. reviews);
  • Distance: the actual distance of the business is from a geo-target.

A visual example of how more reviews can influence ranking for the search query “coffee shops near Union Square”

Due to a recent controversy that was reported in the New York Times, Google Places has most recently made changes to the second category: “prominence.”  Until recently, the prevailing philosophy on local reviews has been that the quantity of reviews outweighed the quality, or the substance of the feedback.  However, the recent changes claim to take both quantity and quality into account when calculating a listing’s prominence.

Of the three categories, businesses have the most control over prominence since relevancy and distance are based on the user’s search query.  Therefore, businesses that have 1) been proactive in improving their service, and 2) responding to negative reviews and focused on solving any complaints/issues have a great advantage in local search.  One can expect Google to continue refining their local algorithm to deliver the very best in its search results, so engagement on local reviews channels continues to be crucial step for businesses.

————————————————————————–
Contributed by: Jonas Pauliukonis, Milestone Internet Marketing

Lo Cal

Recent Posts

Why Context, Not Content, Decides Your AI Visibility

Search did not disappear. It became a qualification system. Google now returns AI answers on…

3 weeks ago

Webinar Recap: Top Tips to Create AI Visibility for Your Hotel

Milestone experts Benu Aggarwal, John Jimenez, and Adam Steeber walked through how AI engines are…

4 weeks ago

US Search Awards 2026: Milestone Shortlisted in Three Categories

We’re excited to announce that Milestone, Inc. has been shortlisted in three categories at the 2026…

4 weeks ago

Building the Knowledge Foundation for AI Discovery: From Schema to Entities

For more than two decades, being found meant earning a place on the results page.…

1 month ago

NLWeb: The first step toward AI-ready Knowledge Layer

AI is creating a new front door to the web. Every major shift on the web…

1 month ago

Webinar Recap: 5 Must-Haves for Hotel Websites in the AI Era and Product Roadmap

Milestone experts Piyush Shrivastava, Tarun Ravindran, and Hardik Modi explored how AI is fundamentally reshaping…

1 month ago